2008 | Greg Marlow (Westfield PD) Scott McKinney (Hamilton Co. Sheriff's Office) | Wayne Druelinger (Fishers PD) |
2009 | Nancy Zellers (Carmel PD) Tim Hendricks (Noblesville PD) | Corey Berfield (Indiana State Police) Dennis Quakenbush (Hamilton Co. Sheriff's Office) |
2010 | Bob Locke (Carmel PD) | Billy J. Adams (Westfield PD) |
2011 | Daniel Nelson (Fishers PD) | Eric Gilbert (Hamilton Co. Sheriff's Office) |
2012 | Brett Bays (Westfield PD) | Andrew Reiss (Noblesville PD) |
2013 | Mike Haskett (Noblesville PD) | Chad Amos (Carmel PD) |
2014 | Willie Collins (Carmel PD) | Kevin Crask (Hamilton Co. Sheriff's Office) |
2015 | Greg Marlow (Westfield PD) | Kevin Silbaugh (Fishers PD) |
2016 | Nancy Zellers (Carmel PD) | Dave Lindenschmidt (Noblesville PD) |
2017 | Scott Goff (Hamilton Co. Sheriff's Office)
| Greg Weesner (Fishers PD) |
2018 | Cesar Rodriguez (Fishers PD) | Michael Steffen (Noblesville PD) |
2019 | Dave Finn (Fishers PD) Mike Haskett (Noblesville PD) | Jarred Koopman & K-9 Harlej (Fishers PD) |
2020 | Kirby Campbell (Fishers PD) | Lydia Fairchok (Sheridan PD) |
2021 | Christopher Bay (Carmel PD) | Jonathan Mathioudakis (Westfield PD) |
2022 | Gregory Loveall (Carmel PD) | Wade Burtron (Westfield PD) Jensen Marie Fionda (Cicero PD) |